YTGET

YouTube · Facebook · X · TikTok · Instagram · Threads

1970年代石油危機如何把景觀建築師送進中東沙漠硬蓋城市

YouTube 影片筆記

1970年代石油危機如何把景觀建築師送進中東沙漠硬蓋城市

原片標題:5. A Celebration of Brian Clouston’s career in Landscape Architecture

原片說明
5. Work in the Middle East Gordon Bell, a young landscape graduate, began working for BCP in 1972 with John Kelsey as partner in charge; colleagues in the office included Jerry Emery, Malc McNulty, Terry Taylor, John Madden, Fritz de Zutter, and office administrator, Janine Thirkettle. After a variety of landscape design and planning projects in S England and Wales, life changed for Gordon and BCP’s future, when he joined consultant Michael Lancaster on a study trip to research plants and techniques suitable for a prestigious new BCP project in Oman. It’s a great story! It was an ironic twist that led Michael Smiley to work with BCP in 1975 on Middle East projects. Made redundant in US at the start of a recession caused by the Middle East oil crisis, luckily one of his friends was Jerry Emery who had been contacted by Brian looking to recruit landscape architects to work in the Middle East. The following week Michael was with BCP. One of his projects was an invited competition for a concept masterplan for Kuwait waterfront. He talks about some of the innovative ideas that they generated. There were projects also in Mecca but they were not allowed in to see or survey the site. Impossible to produce contact documents for the project – or was it? ‘You have just got to get on with it!’ and an unconventional but workable solution was found. He explains how. Michael relished the responsibility and Brian’s entrepreneurial spirit that ran through the practice. Based at the new BCP London office (Covent Garden) for Middle East projects, Alex Novell worked on the masterplan and detail design for the landscape and recreational open space at Yanbu, a 35,000 ha new industrial port and residential city in Saudi Arabia. Eddie Kemp, ecologist and botanist on site identified some vulnerable areas - a wadi and a coastal mangrove swamp and coral reef, and these were included in environmentally protected zones. Another project was in Oman. Using photogrammetry, the original desert location selected for the new Qaboos University was found to be susceptible to flooding, and a more suitable site was found. Using Gordon Bell’s research and experience from other BCP Middle East projects, plants were established using drip feed irrigation. The rate, timing and extent of planting was dependent on the availability of recycled wastewater, the number of students, and if it was term time. An onsite plant nursery was established to supply varieties and quantities. This is the 5th in the Brian Clouston series. The next recording is 6. Work in Asia and Australia https://youtu.be/yKa74jLB5ug The previous recording is 4. Garden Festivals https://youtu.be/ybLHVULGc8k For more information about FOLAR: https://www.folar.uk/ Landscape Institute collection at MERL: https://merl.reading.ac.uk/collections/landscape-institute/ About this series of talks Landscape architect Brian Clouston OBE, past president of the Landscape Institute, established a landscape practice in the 1960s that became multi-disciplinary and operated internationally. By the 1990s it had become one of the leading practices in the UK and employed more people than any other in Europe. FOLAR wanted to learn more about Brian Clouston, what he did, how he attracted so many young talented staff and what type of projects they worked on. FOLAR also wanted to know what they went on to do on leaving BCP. So we invited lots of former staff to tell their stories at an event in September 2023, with Brian Clouston as the star. Brian continues to think about the role and contribution that landscape architects can make to society and to world affairs and in an interview, and he chose this opportunity to discuss his current big vision for Africa. We recorded this event and two interviews with Brian Clouston, as a contribution to the oral history of the profession of landscape architecture. Section One: Introduction; Early days and the formation of the practice; Reclamation; Garden Festivals; Work in

我原本以為這是一場沉悶的建築師聚會,結果根本是三個阿伯在講他們怎麼被丟進沙漠裡、然後硬幹出整座城市的奇幻故事。1974 年石油危機讓一個美國人失業,結果他跑來倫敦,第一份工作竟然是去科威特標海濱規劃案,這也太諷刺了吧。

石油危機讓美國人失業,卻跑來做中東案
石油危機讓美國人失業,卻跑來做中東案03:41

影片時間軸

  1. 00:41Gordon 回憶 1972 年進 BCP,辦公室在泰晤士河畔金斯頓
  2. 01:28接到阿曼蘇丹新宮殿的景觀案,沒人懂沙漠環境怎麼做
  3. 02:04Michael Lancaster 被找來當顧問,要求先去中東實地考察
  4. 02:18Gordon 跟著跑黎巴嫩、伊朗、杜拜,最後到阿曼看基地
  5. 03:41Michael Smiley 解釋自己為何從加州跑來倫敦工作
  6. 03:531974 年阿拉伯石油禁運讓美國陷入衰退,他被裁員
  7. 05:00朋友 Jerry Emery 接到 Brian 電話要人,Michael 一週內就上工
  8. 05:32第一個大案是科威特海濱總體規劃,五家國際事務所受邀競圖
  9. 06:43提出半潮堰讓海水留住形成水池,還能划船
  10. 07:26三個月內做完所有圖說與模型,Michael 說他幾乎做兩倍工時
  11. 07:53接著是麥加兩座大公園,但團隊根本進不去現場
  12. 09:41沒有測量圖、只有幾張照片和零星高程點,照樣把案子做完
  13. 12:39Alex 講紅海邊的 Yanbu,三萬五千公頃,大到要另開一間辦公室
  14. 14:11每次審查都被退一堆修改,他至今還記得「承包商應配合」這句話
  15. 15:12最後講 Kaboos 案,發現基地在暴雨下會淹水一公尺,只好換地方
科威特海濱競圖,三個人站在圖前
科威特海濱競圖,三個人站在圖前05:32

被石油危機推來的人

Michael Smiley 的故事最荒謬。1974 年阿拉伯石油禁運把美國經濟打趴,他這個入行兩年的景觀建築師當然第一個被砍。結果朋友 Jerry Emery 接到 Brian 電話說要徵中東案的人,下週他就坐在倫敦辦公室了。因為石油危機失業,然後立刻去做中東案子,他自己都說這叫諷刺。那個年代的人找工作好像沒在挑的,有電話就上。

麥加案只能看照片,現場根本進不去
麥加案只能看照片,現場根本進不去07:53

沒有測量圖也要蓋公園

麥加那兩座公園的段落才是整場演講的重點。受過訓練的人都知道,沒有基地測量圖就等於準備被告,但他們只有幾張照片、幾個高程點,還進不了聖城。Michael 的解法是把整座公園當成一艘船來設計,所有設施相對於彼此定位,高程自己抓一組合理的,剩下的留給承包商進場調整。他說這件事改變了他一輩子,有時候就是得硬幹。

Yanbu 大到要另外開一間辦公室來管
Yanbu 大到要另外開一間辦公室來管12:39

紅海邊那座黑潭

Alex 講 Yanbu 的語氣最好笑。三萬五千公頃的新工業城,他直接說是「紅海邊的黑潭」,有海噴泉、度假村、海濱步道,設計得很花俏。但控制他們的是 Parsons,每次審查都退回一整排修改意見,他早上醒來腦裡還響著「承包商應配合」。更慘的是他後來查 Google Maps,發現當年那套想像力十足的設計,跟現場幾乎對不起來。

發現基地會淹水,只好重新找地方
發現基地會淹水,只好重新找地方15:12

淹水一公尺的意外收穫

Kaboos 案是少數他說做得很開心的案子。一開始用攝影測量做地形圖,才發現那塊素地遇到暴雨會淹到一公尺深,只好繼續往外找,最後找到被地形包圍、有中軸線、末端還有個小丘可以放清真寺的完美基地。他也提到從 Jeddah 案學到的滴灌技術,讓沙漠砂土裡的鹽分能被水帶下去。這段是整場少見的技術乾貨。

值得下載嗎

值得,如果你對中東現代城市規劃或景觀建築的實務有興趣,這兩段第一手回憶很難得。但如果只是想看熱鬧,前二十分鐘的辦公室人事介紹可以快轉。

覺得這篇筆記有幫助嗎?
YTGet 編輯室|看完影片整理的筆記,細節以原片為準。

連線中

影片封面

擷取畫面

輸入時間點,例如 3:20、3.20 或 200

影片皆已含音訊。檔案越大準備時間越久,完成前請保持頁面開啟。