This was the trial episode of Completion Critiques, using a different name, as I tried to figure out what the format I wanted it to be. I wanted to talk about how we can use achievements to track the overall engagement and success of a game's design among its consumer base. I chose Hollow Knight for episode 1. The ending was added on after the stream to try and come up with a more accurate way of using the information to measure what a game did. If you have any suggestions or feedback, please let me know. The ending with the changes starts at 34:41
_____________________________________________________________
#gamedesign #gamedev #videogames
BOOKS I'VE WRITTEN ON GAME DESIGN:
Game Design Deep Dive: Roguelikes -- https://www.routledge.com/Game-Design-Deep-Dive-Roguelikes/Bycer/p/book/9780367638191
Game Design Deep Dive: Platformers -- https://www.crcpress.com/Game-Design-Deep-Dive-Jumping-Platformers/Bycer/p/book/9780367211387
20 Essential Games to Study: -- https://www.crcpress.com/20-Essential-Games-to-Study/Bycer/p/book/9781138341456
JOIN OUR DISCORD CHANNEL
The basic tier is now open to everyone with additional features and options for those who support our Patreon. Anyone on the discord also gets the archives of our game streams for free. https://discord.gg/MFdkhMz
SUPPORT GAME-WISDOM
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/GWBycer
Hitting goals will allow me to add more content and let patreon supporters vote on what they would like to see each month.
If you would like to make a one-time donation -- You can send money directly through Paypal through this link: http://paypal.me/GWBycer
SUBSCRIBE AND FOLLOW:
Become a Member of the Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJPQyAGAbIcXZXfM01oOPOA/join
Main Site: http://Game-Wisdom.com
YouTube: http://youtube.com/c/game-wisdom
Twitter: https://twitter.com/gwbycer
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/gamewisdom/
Audiocasts can be found at: http://subscribeonandroid.com/game-wisdom.com/feed/podcast for Android and https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/game-wisdom/id1126129621?mt=2&ls=1 for Itunes
ABOUT ME:
I'm Josh Bycer and I run the site Game-Wisdom, where I examine the art and science of games. Here on Youtube, I put out a variety of videos that consists of let's plays, examinations and more.
我玩《空洞騎士》大概死到第三個 boss 就放棄了,所以看到 Game Wisdom 說有 25% 的人連半小時都撐不過去,我其實有點安慰。這支影片拿成就解鎖率當工具,去算一款遊戲到底留住多少人、在哪裡開始崩。Game Wisdom 選《空洞騎士》當第一集,因為它評價極高但玩家流失也很兇,正好拿來測試這套評分方法行不行得通。
主線打最終 boss 的成就只有 19.2%,Game Wisdom 說這在他們的量表上大概是 D 到 F。真結局相關成就 14.5%,DLC 內容更低。但他也補充,真結局 boss 難度更高、要打兩格傷害,完成率低不完全是設計問題。這段他反覆確認哪個成就對應哪個結局,看得出來成就說明不夠清楚也造成他判讀上的麻煩。